Review Form - RNA NanoMed

Reviewer *

Reviewer Email *

RN# *

Date completed

Title

Review Item

1. NoveltyExcellentGoodAcceptablePoorVery Poor1. Does the paper introduce new problems, theories, or methods? 2. Does it use innovative techniques or approaches to advance the field? 3. Does it address significant unresolved issues in current research?

2. SignificanceExcellentGoodAcceptablePoorVery Poor1. Is the research significant, with potential to advance theoretical or practical developments in the field? 2. How impactful are the results for academia or industry? 3. Does it offer clear practical applications or theoretical insights?

3. Data ConclusionsExcellentGoodAcceptablePoorVery Poor1. Are the data sufficient, accurate, and reliable? 2. Are the research methods reasonable and scientifically sound? 3. Were appropriate statistical analyses used? 4. Are there any weaknesses in experimental design, and does the data adequately support the conclusions?

4. Impact Factor & Journal FitExcellentGoodAcceptablePoorVery Poor1. Does the paper align with the journal's scope and field? 2. Could the research have a significant impact on mainstream academic or industry topics? 3. Does it match the editorial policies and publication focus of the journal?

5. Structure & PresentationExcellentGoodAcceptablePoorVery Poor1. Is the paper's organization logical and well-structured? 2. Is there clear logical flow between sections? 3. Are figures and appendices clear and support the main points of the paper?

6. Literature Review & BackgroundExcellentGoodAcceptablePoorVery Poor1. Is the literature review comprehensive and adequately supports the research background? 2. Are there any significant omissions in the literature? 3. Are references to prior research appropriate and provide new perspectives?

7. Language QualityExcellentGoodAcceptablePoorVery Poor1. Is the language clear, accurate, and easy to understand? 2. Are there spelling or grammatical errors?

Suggestion *

Comments to author (Summary)

Comments to author (Attachment)

No file chosen

RNA NanoMed Electronic Review Form

About Us

Company

Services

Support